--- title: Monetizing your First-Party Identity Graph description: Publishers building their own first-party data graph have a myriad of ways to leverage this data to enrich existing and build new revenue streams. image: https://info.growthcode.io/hubfs/IdentityHero-Money-1.png --- [![growthcode-HORIZ-BlueHR](https://info.growthcode.io/hs-fs/hubfs/growthcode-HORIZ-BlueHR.png?width=182&height=37&name=growthcode-HORIZ-BlueHR.png "growthcode-HORIZ-BlueHR")](http://www.growthcode.io) - Product - [Platform](https://www.growthcode.io/platform) - [GRAPH](https://www.growthcode.io/graph) - [ENRICH](https://www.growthcode.io/enrich) - [INSIGHTS](https://www.growthcode.io/insights) - [CURATE](https://www.growthcode.io/curate) - [ROSETTA](https://www.growthcode.io/rosetta) - Solutions - [For Publishers](https://www.growthcode.io/publishers) - [For Brands & Buyers](https://www.growthcode.io/demand) - [For DSPs & SSPs](https://www.growthcode.io/dsp-ssp) - [About](https://www.growthcode.io/about) - Resources - [Blog](https://info.growthcode.io/blog) - [Downloads](https://info.growthcode.io/growthcode-downloads) - [GrowthCode Glossary](https://www.growthcode.io/growthcode-glossary-of-addressability-terms) - [Documentation](https://docs.growthcode.io/) - [Login](https://dashboard.firstparty.id/login) [Log In](https://dashboard.firstparty.id/login) ![Monetizing your First-Party Identity Graph](https://info.growthcode.io/hubfs/IdentityHero-Money-1.png) [Back to main blog](https://info.growthcode.io/blog) [first-party data](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/first-party-data) [identity](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/identity) # Monetizing your First-Party Identity Graph on December 6, 2023 ## How do I make money once I have a first-party identity graph?. Once you have a Firsty-Party Data Graph, the next logical question is, "How can I turn this valuable asset into revenue?" In this article, we'll explore several revenue-generating strategies that leverage your first-party data to address the evolving landscape of digital advertising. ## **![IdentityHero-Money-1](https://info.growthcode.io/hs-fs/hubfs/IdentityHero-Money-1.png?width=1024&height=629&name=IdentityHero-Money-1.png)** ## **1. Direct Sales** Direct sales have been a cornerstone for publishers but come with challenges, especially for smaller players. You'll need a Data Management Platform (DMP)or similar data platform to create custom audience segments to succeed in this space. Additionally, licensing demographic data is often necessary to meet advertisers' specific targeting requirements. However, the rising costs of DMPs and the human resources needed for managing direct deals can pose challenges for smaller publishers. Licensing and managing a full-service DMP rarely pays for all but the largest publishers. Over the last two years, lighter-weight DMPs have emerged, and some DMP vendors have given away their technology for rights to data and media assets.  Pros:  - Precise targeting control over campaigns - Significantly higher CPMs - Predictability Cons:  - High operational costs  - Resource-intensive - Additional technology expense Within direct sales, publishers can use emerging privacy-enhancing technologies like data clean rooms to match publisher first-party data with brand CRM data. These buys typically have less scale but deterministically target the exact user a buyer seeks - and they pay more to reach them.  While a complicated process requiring overhead, it does empower publishers to create deep and sticky relationships with key buyers to curate exactly what these buyers need. ### **2. Bid Signal Enrichment** Bid Signal Enrichment is an innovative approach to leverage 1st-party data. Publishers share their first-party data with potential buyers in the bid request to make sure the buyer understands the impression better, thus enhancing the value of impressions. This strategy shifts the focus from third-party to first-party data sources, aligning with online privacy trends. Pros: - Enhanced impression value  - Data-driven decision-making Cons:  - Technical complexity - Buyer-specific requirements - Changing protocols and processes make this complex for a publisher to manage alone ### **3. Building Private Marketplaces (PMPs)** Private Marketplaces (PMPs) offer premium ad inventory to select advertisers. Using 1st-party data for PMPs involves syncing your data with Supply-Side Platforms (SSPs) or Demand-Side Platforms (DSPs). This enables you to tap into traditional Real-Time Bidding (RTB) channels. Pros:  - Premium ad inventory  - Targeted ad placements - Higher COMs than Open se Cons:  - Small publishers may face challenges partnering with SSPs and DSPs - Seat needed on SSP to create Deal ID - Staff and infrastructure needed to support  - Complex process from end to end to do alone ### **4. Reach Extension and Retargeting** Reach extension involves using your first-party data to target your existing audience and similar audiences across different platforms and websites. This expands your audience and boosts ad rates and the ability to service a client’s demand/reach requirements – ultimately increasing revenue. Pros:  - Audience growth - Improved ad rates - Fulfillment of client requirements Cons:  - Data quality - Compliance considerations - Requires additional overhead and seats on SSPS or DSPs ### **5. Data Sales** In the digital advertising landscape, data is invaluable. First-party data generated from direct user interactions provides a clear view of audience behaviors and preferences. Publishers can package and sell this data to advertisers seeking reliable information if appropriately consented. Pros:  - New revenue stream - Actionable data segments Cons:  - Evolving technology - Standardization challenges - Need for scale - Privacy concerns - Brand concerns (pub relationship to users) ### **Conclusion** The future is coming faster than we might like: ![](https://lh7-us.googleusercontent.com/Zf9fP_jy7Eexy4OemFvMSKzCRSrKPOZGASblmAfw-PSkIOz08hs64e4AGs57TMfHRWbRHyMoDGq39Zuj5XbtzkeYlZ9loYNiv3Gi7POny2nNdK79ogi5euAbuiMPux66so2Q9UGDfonOMIUzKyEANvA) In the dynamic world of digital advertising, possessing a first-party identity graph provides a bridge to the cookieless future and presents a myriad of revenue opportunities at your fingertips. Yet, it's essential to acknowledge that navigating these opportunities and successfully monetizing your first-party data requires a well-thought-out strategy. Sitting on your hands is no longer an option. Fortunately, these processes can be easily managed with the right partner by your side. As we've explored various revenue-generating strategies, it's clear that each avenue presents its unique set of advantages and challenges.  - Direct sales, while offering precise targeting control and higher CPMs, can be resource-intensive and costly.  - Bid Signal Enrichment, an innovative approach, enhances impression value.  However, the current deployments are cumbersome, SSPs are inconsistent in their absorption of these signals and can cause page performance issues.  - Building Private Marketplaces (PMPs) unlocks premium ad inventory but may pose hurdles for smaller publishers in terms of partnerships and infrastructure.  - Reach Extension and Retargeting broaden your audience and boost ad rates but require careful data management and compliance considerations.  - Lastly, Data Sales can open up a new revenue stream but comes with evolving technology and privacy concerns. The key takeaway is that while the revenue potential is vast, choosing the right path and effectively managing it is crucial. This is where a partnership with a trusted and transparent vendor becomes invaluable. Such a partner can help you navigate the intricate terrain of adtech, offering solutions that streamline operations, mitigate challenges, and maximize your returns. Whether you're a seasoned online media veteran or a newcomer, the intersection of data, identity, and monetization is ever-evolving. Adapting to these changes and making the most of your first-party data asset requires a strategic mindset. By considering the expertise of the right vendor, you can confidently navigate this landscape, ensuring that your first-party identity graph becomes a powerful engine for revenue growth as you continue to build your community and quality content.  ### Subscribe to the GrowthCode Blog ## Similar articles [first-party data](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/first-party-data) [identity](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/identity) ##### [Understanding the Costs of First-Party Data Graphs](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/understanding-costs-of-first-party-data-graphs) By [Trip Foster](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/trip-foster) on February 12, 2025 In the evolving landscape of digital advertising, building a robust first-party data graph and enriching bid requests are pivotal for maximizing addressability and driving value for both... [Read More](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/understanding-costs-of-first-party-data-graphs) 4 min read [first-party data](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/first-party-data) [identity](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/identity) ##### [Rating Data Types for Building the New Publisher Currency](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/rating-the-data-types-for-graph-building) By [Jonathon Shaevitz](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/jonathon-shaevitz) on October 25, 2023 When publishers inventory their data, some types are better than others for creating the key data feedstock asset [Read More](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/rating-the-data-types-for-graph-building) 6 min read [first-party data](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/first-party-data) [identity](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/identity) ##### [The foundations of the new first-party data currency](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/the-foundations-of-the-new-first-party-data-currency) By [Jonathon Shaevitz](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/jonathon-shaevitz) on November 1, 2023 In an era where third-party cookies are on their way out, digital publishers are pivoting to a more controlled and sustainable, privacy-focused approach to data collection and monetization. [Read More](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/the-foundations-of-the-new-first-party-data-currency) 6 min read [first-party data](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/first-party-data) [curation](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/curation) ##### [Maximize Profits: Use First-Party Data to Build New Revenue Streams](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/maximizing-publisher-profits-utilizing-first-party-data-for-revenue-generation-in-established-marketplaces) By [Trip Foster](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/trip-foster) on July 25, 2023 As the ecosystem transitions to the use of publisher first-party data (1PD) as the currency for targeting, Publishers are getting smart on other ways to leverage their investment in 1PD to... [Read More](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/maximizing-publisher-profits-utilizing-first-party-data-for-revenue-generation-in-established-marketplaces) 3 min read [first-party data](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/first-party-data) [neutral infrastructure](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/neutral-infrastructure) ##### [How publishers can future-proof monetization.](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/how-publishers-can-future-proof-monetization) By [Trip Foster](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/trip-foster) on December 8, 2022 Signal loss and the art of stack maintenance As Publishers, we've been hearing for years that the sky is falling due to the deprecation of the third-party cookie. Yet with each passing... [Read More](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/how-publishers-can-future-proof-monetization) 4 min read [first-party data](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/first-party-data) [addressability](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/addressability) ##### [The Rosetta Stone & Bridge to the Future for Independent Publishers](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/first-party-data-rosetta-stone) By [Jonathon Shaevitz](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/jonathon-shaevitz) on October 16, 2023 The cookie’s demise has led to dozens of different planning, activation, and measurement techniques without the cookie. Many seek to leverage first-party data. [Read More](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/first-party-data-rosetta-stone) 5 min read [first-party data](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/first-party-data) [signal ownership](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/signal-ownership) ##### [The golden opportunity for independent digital publishers](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/golden-opportunity-for-digital-publishers) By [Jonathon Shaevitz](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/jonathon-shaevitz) on October 3, 2023 The first party-data asset is the new currency. Denying this fact or not acting on this moment to create and secure these first-party assets will leave publisher roadkill. [Read More](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/golden-opportunity-for-digital-publishers) 4 min read [first-party data](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/first-party-data) [identity](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/identity) ##### [Navigating the Shift to First-Party Audience Data: Opportunities and Challenges](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/navigating-the-shift-to-first-party-data) By [Jonathon Shaevitz](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/jonathon-shaevitz) on January 2, 2024 Publishers and vendors face new challenges and opportunities as the advertising industry shifts from third-party cookies to first-party data. This article outlines key strategies to empower... [Read More](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/navigating-the-shift-to-first-party-data) 9 min read [first-party data](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/first-party-data) [signal ownership](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/signal-ownership) [open web](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/open-web) [infrastructure](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/infrastructure) [neutrality](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/neutrality) ##### [The Open Web Is a Network of Nodes – That Should Change How You Compete.](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/the-open-web-is-a-network-of-nodes) By [Trip Foster](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/trip-foster) on June 29, 2026 [Read More](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/the-open-web-is-a-network-of-nodes) 3 min read [Universal IDs](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/universal-ids) [first-party data](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/first-party-data) [bid enrichment](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/bid-enrichment) [cookie-deprecation](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/cookie-deprecation) ##### [The accurate and responsible use of UIDs and Identity will destroy The Identity Bridge to nowhere](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/destroying-the-identity-bridge-to-nowhere) By [Jonathon Shaevitz](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/jonathon-shaevitz) on June 10, 2024 UID Predictability Is a precondition for UIDs and post-cookie addressability to succeed. Short-sighted fraud will destroy the ecosystem. Chase the rats out of the kitchen. (Part 2 in the... [Read More](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/destroying-the-identity-bridge-to-nowhere) 4 min read [![growthcode logo](https://info.growthcode.io/hs-fs/hubfs/growthcode-HORIZ-orange.png?width=180&height=29&name=growthcode-HORIZ-orange.png "growthcode logo")](http://www.growthcode.io) ##### Simplifying Addressability. Amplifying Revenue. [About us](http://www.growthcode.io) About The Platform - [Platform](https://www.growthcode.io/platform) - [Graph](https://www.growthcode.io/graph) - [Enrich](https://www.growthcode.io/enrich) - [Insights](https://www.growthcode.io/insights) - [Curate](https://www.growthcode.io/curate) - [Rosetta](https://www.growthcode.io/rosetta) Solutions - [Publishers](https://www.growthcode.io/publishers) - [Demand](https://www.growthcode.io/demand) - [DSPs & SSPs](https://www.growthcode.io/dsp-ssp) Resources - [Blog](https://info.growthcode.io/blog) - [Downloads](https://info.growthcode.io/growthcode-downloads) - [Docs](https://docs.growthcode.io) - [Glossary](https://www.growthcode.io/growthcode-glossary-of-terms) © 2025 GrowthCode | [Privacy Policy](https://www.growthcode.io/privacy) | [Do Not Sell My Info](https://www.growthcode.io/do-not-sell-or-share-my-personal-information)     ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@type" : "BlogPosting", "author" : { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "Jonathon Shaevitz", "url" : "https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/jonathon-shaevitz" }, "dateModified" : "2026-07-17T21:25:44.655Z", "datePublished" : "2023-12-06T13:50:39.000Z", "headline" : "Monetizing your First-Party Identity Graph", "image" : [ "https://info.growthcode.io/hubfs/IdentityHero-Money-1.png" ], "mainEntityOfPage" : { "@id" : "https://info.growthcode.io/blog/monetizing-the-publisher-first-party-graph", "@type" : "WebPage" }, "publisher" : { "@type" : "Organization", "logo" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "url" : "https://info.growthcode.io/hubfs/growthcode-HORIZ-Blue-1.png" }, "name" : "Growthcode" } } ```