--- title: "Publishers: Stop blaming Google. Examine Their Priorities and Incentives Instead." description: Google keeps punting on cookie deprecation because they are only clear on what they want for themselves and not their role in the broader health of the open web. image: https://info.growthcode.io/hubfs/SchitzCookie2.jpeg --- [![growthcode-HORIZ-BlueHR](https://info.growthcode.io/hs-fs/hubfs/growthcode-HORIZ-BlueHR.png?width=182&height=37&name=growthcode-HORIZ-BlueHR.png "growthcode-HORIZ-BlueHR")](http://www.growthcode.io) - Product - [Platform](https://www.growthcode.io/platform) - [GRAPH](https://www.growthcode.io/graph) - [ENRICH](https://www.growthcode.io/enrich) - [INSIGHTS](https://www.growthcode.io/insights) - [CURATE](https://www.growthcode.io/curate) - [ROSETTA](https://www.growthcode.io/rosetta) - Solutions - [For Publishers](https://www.growthcode.io/publishers) - [For Brands & Buyers](https://www.growthcode.io/demand) - [For DSPs & SSPs](https://www.growthcode.io/dsp-ssp) - [About](https://www.growthcode.io/about) - Resources - [Blog](https://info.growthcode.io/blog) - [Downloads](https://info.growthcode.io/growthcode-downloads) - [GrowthCode Glossary](https://www.growthcode.io/growthcode-glossary-of-addressability-terms) - [Documentation](https://docs.growthcode.io/) - [Login](https://dashboard.firstparty.id/login) [Log In](https://dashboard.firstparty.id/login) ![Publishers: Stop blaming Google. Examine Their Priorities and Incentives Instead.](https://info.growthcode.io/hubfs/SchitzCookie2.jpeg) [Back to main blog](https://info.growthcode.io/blog) [first-party data](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/first-party-data) [open web](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/open-web) # Publishers: Stop blaming Google. Examine Their Priorities and Incentives Instead. on July 29, 2024 ### **Google's Cookie Conundrum: A Publisher's Perspective** In a surprising (?) twist, Google has decided to keep third-party cookies on the menu for Chrome users, stirring up a mix of relief and confusion among online publishers. The tech giant's schitzo pivot from its initial plan to scrap these digital trackers has left many wondering: **what's cooking in the Chrome kitchen?** Google's new recipe for user privacy introduces user choice, allowing users to opt-in or out of cookies as they please. This uncertainty about how this new policy will work means publishers have to plan for everything. If the new Chrome defaults to “opt out”, this is basically putting the cookie into a vegetative state, but not actually killing it. It also makes the user the decider to deprecate the cookie versus Google being the one to do this (and face [antitrust](https://adtechexplained.com/why-is-google-no-longer-deprecating-cookies/)). Alternatively, if the default is “opt in”, they preserve the cookie’s continued slow decline. Finally, this à la carte approach to browsing data could see users cherry-picking their privacy settings site-by-site, potentially leaving publishers to face an inconsistent scenario when it comes to ad targeting capabilities.  That said, the Privacy Sandbox, Google's playground for developing privacy-preserving tech, remains open for business. Some have even posited that Google’s continued lack of leadership points to the desire it has  to have more time cooking the Privacy Sandbox to improve it’s [negative results](https://digiday.com/media/publishers-privacy-sandbox-pauses-settle-into-a-deep-freeze-following-reports-of-poor-performance/) and poor market uptake. Larger, richer publishers who've invested in this complex and sometimes puzzling initiative can breathe a sigh of relief—those Sandbox APIs aren't going anywhere - but half-baked proposals still remain and lack performance.  Given the lack of any clear guidance or leadership, many have postulated that Google's latest move, position its offerings to maintain market dominance while appeasing regulators with a veneer of user empowerment. Suggestions from many publishers we have talked to seem to point to the assumption that if the user does opt-out, then the assumed fall back will be the Privacy Sandbox, where Google will look to assert advantages it may have with its own SSP (as it did prior to the advent of Header Bidding).  ### **The cost? The independent web is worse off again.** So, why isn't Google tossing cookies for good as planned? It seems the company is wary of anti-trust allegations, as the Privacy Sandbox has shown signs of really hurting ad revenue, with some tests revealing a 60% drop. By keeping cookies on the table and messy, Google can continue to sweeten its high-margin ventures like search and YouTube, and monetization of its own first-party relationships with users–all while theoretically keeping competitors at arm's length by empowering end users to say 'no' to cookies. The big question is if Google will pattern the user experience to opt-out by default like Apple's ATT or, default them users as opted-in by default. Google's strategy is clever yet self-serving. By giving users the power to deprecate cookies themselves, Google can potentially weaken open web advertising, and drive more aforementioned dollars towards its own higher-margin, and more trackable platforms (YouTube, Search) and dressing up its dominance as a commitment to privacy. Remember, Google already possesses one the best first-party consented user graphs in the world, competing only with Amazon, Meta, and maybe Apple.  For publishers, this means navigating a landscape where Google's decisions cast a long shadow. The uncertainty around Chrome's cookie consent workflow and its implementation timeline adds to the complexity of planning digital advertising strategies. Will publishers have to grovel for cookie consent, or will they be left to rely on the less palatable and poor-performing Privacy Sandbox APIs to monetize their content? As always with Google, to answer the question of what Google wants publishers to do comes from asking what is more profitable to Google. In this case, what we are hearing from publishers is that the attitude to publishers seems to be: “If you can get third-party cookies … keep at it, we will keep taking your money (but good luck after our Chrome prompts!). If you can't get the cookie, invest resources you don't have in the Sandbox as the fall back (where we also get revenue and data) …or just give up and we’ll tell our advertisers to buy our other stuff that we control.” The industry is now at a crossroads, with a $225 billion question mark hanging over its head. As Google continues to stir the pot, publishers must stay alert and adaptable, ready to adjust their strategies in response to the tech giant's ever-shifting game plan. One thing to never lose sight of -- regardless of antitrust, bouts with regulators, user privacy or other external forces -- their incentives never change. The future of digital advertising is still being baked, and publishers will need to ensure they don't end up with a tiny slice of a half-baked revenue pie by over relying on a vendor that is bent on taking the whole pie on their own terms.  So where does this leave the different segments of the ecosystem? #### ** What Publishers Should Do Now** 1. 1. 1. Bid density increases 2. Higher eCPMs 3. Higher CTR rates #### ** What SSPs Should Do Now** #### ** What DSPs Should Do Now** #### ** What Advertisers Should Do Now** 1. **Strengthen First-Party Data:** Focus on building robust first-party data assets and strategies, including CRM integration, loyalty programs, and direct consumer engagement. 2. **Explore Contextual Advertising:** Invest in contextual advertising solutions that do not rely on third-party cookies but still provide effective targeting. These can be blended with other targeting strategies. 3. **Partner with Trusted Platforms:** Collaborate with platforms that prioritize user privacy and offer transparent data practices to ensure brand safety and compliance. Also make sure you arent working with vendors that practice nefarious methods to stuff fraudulent impressions. 4. **Stay Agile:** Maintain flexibility in ad spend allocation and be ready to shift strategies based on evolving industry practices and regulatory changes.   ## Similar articles [first-party data](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/first-party-data) [curation](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/curation) ##### [Nuances of SDA: when & why will publishers will invest in it (pt 2)](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/nuances-of-sda-and-when-and-why-will-publishers-will-invest-in-sda-part-2) By [Trip Foster](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/trip-foster) on November 21, 2022 As with all things adtech… Seller Defined Audiences (SDA) is complicated (Part 2 in our Seller Defined Audience briefing) See part 1 here As always, the devil is in the details.... [Read More](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/nuances-of-sda-and-when-and-why-will-publishers-will-invest-in-sda-part-2) 3 min read [bid enrichment](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/bid-enrichment) [identity](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/identity) ##### [The New Rules of Addressability: Why 7+ IDs Is the Sweet Spot for Prebid Uplift](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/why-7-ids-is-the-sweet-spot-for-prebid-uplift) By [Trip Foster](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/trip-foster) on July 15, 2025 In the evolving world of programmatic advertising, publishers are looking for every edge they can find. With third-party cookies crumbling, search traffic cratering and signal loss... [Read More](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/why-7-ids-is-the-sweet-spot-for-prebid-uplift) 5 min read [signal ownership](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/signal-ownership) [agentic advertising](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/agentic-advertising) ##### [When the Buyer Is a Bot, Whose Signal Does It Trust?](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/when-the-buyer-is-a-bot) By [Trip Foster](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/trip-foster) on July 15, 2026 AI is going to change media buying at a pace no human trading desk could match. Decisions happening in milliseconds. Spend reallocated across thousands of auctions a second. [Read More](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/when-the-buyer-is-a-bot) 4 min read [bid enrichment](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/bid-enrichment) [addressability](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/addressability) ##### [Multi-Signal: Maximizing Addressability for Open RTB and Deal ID Campaigns](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/multi-signal-adressability) By [Trip Foster](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/trip-foster) on January 21, 2025 [Read More](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/multi-signal-adressability) 3 min read [bid enrichment](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/bid-enrichment) [identity](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/identity) ##### [Innovations in Bid Enrichment. We have arrived at 2.0](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/bid-enrichment-innovations) By [Jonathon Shaevitz](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/jonathon-shaevitz) on March 27, 2025 The advertising landscape is evolving rapidly, and more sophisticated tools are needed to maximize ad performance. Bid enrichment with universal ID signals has recently become a critical... [Read More](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/bid-enrichment-innovations) 5 min read [addressability](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/addressability) [identity](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/identity) ##### [Will Universal IDs replace the 3rd-party cookie?](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/will-universal-ids-replace-the-3rd-party-cookie) By [Trip Foster](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/trip-foster) on July 10, 2023 What are they? Universal IDs (UIDs) are a type of identifier that can be legally used to track users across multiple websites. They are designed to replace third-party cookies, which... [Read More](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/will-universal-ids-replace-the-3rd-party-cookie) 5 min read [first-party data](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/first-party-data) [addressability](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/addressability) ##### [Modern Addressability in Digital Advertising: The Marketer Cheat Sheet](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/modern-marketer-addressability) By [Trip Foster](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/trip-foster) on January 16, 2025 Cracking the Marketer's Code for the Future of Digital Ad Targeting The advertising landscape has undergone a seismic shift, with privacy concerns, third-party cookie deprecation, and... [Read More](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/modern-marketer-addressability) 4 min read [signal ownership](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/signal-ownership) [agentic advertising](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/agentic-advertising) ##### [Whose Model Gets Smarter From Your Campaigns?](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/whose-model-gets-smarter-from-your-campaigns) By [Trip Foster](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/trip-foster) on July 8, 2026 Training data is the advantage. Do you know where yours is going? [Read More](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/whose-model-gets-smarter-from-your-campaigns) 4 min read [first-party data](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/first-party-data) [bid enrichment](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/bid-enrichment) ##### [How publishers of any size can capture "Disney Magic"](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/how-publishers-of-all-sizes-can-capture-disney-magic) By [Trip Foster](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/trip-foster) on September 10, 2025 Mid-to-Long Tail Publishers can unlock Disney-grade first-party data Ad Revenue strategies with GrowthCode Disney's ad tech strategy is a masterclass in modern media monetization. They've... [Read More](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/how-publishers-of-all-sizes-can-capture-disney-magic) 3 min read [first-party data](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/first-party-data) [open web](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/tag/open-web) ##### [Another False Lifeline](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/3rd-party-cookie-false-lifeline) By [Jonathon Shaevitz](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/jonathon-shaevitz) on April 24, 2025 Why the Market will Continue to Pivot to First-Party Data and Stop Its Preoccupation with Chrome’s ‘Legacy’ 3rd Party Cookie. Google’s decision to retain third-party cookies in Chrome is a... [Read More](https://info.growthcode.io/blog/3rd-party-cookie-false-lifeline) 6 min read [![growthcode logo](https://info.growthcode.io/hs-fs/hubfs/growthcode-HORIZ-orange.png?width=180&height=29&name=growthcode-HORIZ-orange.png "growthcode logo")](http://www.growthcode.io) ##### Simplifying Addressability. Amplifying Revenue. [About us](http://www.growthcode.io) About The Platform - [Platform](https://www.growthcode.io/platform) - [Graph](https://www.growthcode.io/graph) - [Enrich](https://www.growthcode.io/enrich) - [Insights](https://www.growthcode.io/insights) - [Curate](https://www.growthcode.io/curate) - [Rosetta](https://www.growthcode.io/rosetta) Solutions - [Publishers](https://www.growthcode.io/publishers) - [Demand](https://www.growthcode.io/demand) - [DSPs & SSPs](https://www.growthcode.io/dsp-ssp) Resources - [Blog](https://info.growthcode.io/blog) - [Downloads](https://info.growthcode.io/growthcode-downloads) - [Docs](https://docs.growthcode.io) - [Glossary](https://www.growthcode.io/growthcode-glossary-of-terms) © 2025 GrowthCode | [Privacy Policy](https://www.growthcode.io/privacy) | [Do Not Sell My Info](https://www.growthcode.io/do-not-sell-or-share-my-personal-information)     ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@type" : "BlogPosting", "author" : { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "Jonathon Shaevitz", "url" : "https://info.growthcode.io/blog/author/jonathon-shaevitz" }, "dateModified" : "2026-07-17T22:40:16.993Z", "datePublished" : "2024-07-29T11:15:00.000Z", "headline" : "Publishers: Stop blaming Google. Examine Their Priorities and Incentives Instead.", "image" : [ "https://info.growthcode.io/hubfs/SchitzCookie2.jpeg" ], "mainEntityOfPage" : { "@id" : "https://info.growthcode.io/blog/googles-priorities-and-incentives", "@type" : "WebPage" }, "publisher" : { "@type" : "Organization", "logo" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "url" : "https://info.growthcode.io/hubfs/growthcode-HORIZ-Blue-1.png" }, "name" : "Growthcode" } } ```